South Dakota quarterback Austyn Modrzewski’s first-quarter fumble was ruled to be an incomplete pass by a replay booth review Saturday at Hancock Stadium. (Photo by GoRedbirds.com)
By Dan Verdun
NORMAL – On an unseasonably near-perfect fall day, Illinois State couldn’t match the beautiful weather in its regular-season home finale.
No. 6 South Dakota defeated No. 11/13 ISU, 10-3, under sunny skies and upper-60 degree temperatures Saturday afternoon at Hancock Stadium.
The win boosted South Dakota to a 9-3 overall record (6-2 Missouri Valley Football Conference) and likely locked up a Top-8 seed and first-round playoff bye for the Coyotes.
Illinois State (8-4, 4-4) will learn if it makes the 24-team FCS post-season field as an at-large team when the bracket is revealed at 11 a.m. Sunday on ESPNU.
If ISU receives the playoff slot, it marks the third straight year the Redbirds would make the postseason. ISU previously accomplished that feat 2014-16 under Spack.

As for Saturday’s loss to South Dakota, Illinois State was done in by a lackluster offense and two defensive errors that cost the Redbirds mightily.
ISU produced 270 yards of offense and committed no penalties yet could only muster a 33-yard field goal by Michael Cosentino for a 3-0 halftime lead.
The Redbirds managed just 110 rushing yards on 35 attempts (3.1 average). Seniors Victor Dawson and Seth Glatz each ran for 34 yards.
“We couldn’t get a lot going. When we run the football, we’re really dangerous,” ISU head coach Brock Spack said. “We struggled to get the running game going.”
Quarterback Beckham Pellant managed to rush for 33 yards. However, the junior completed 19 of 42 passes for 160 yards. He was intercepted once.
“He was a little off today. He wasn’t as accurate as he’s been,” Spack said. “The further the ball got thrown down the field, I think the better he was. It was kind of a weird day that way.”
Pellant said: “I was inaccurate today . . . Those incompletions kill drives, especially on crucial downs and when the receiver is open. I’ve got to get my feet under me and trust the throws.”
South Dakota produced two explosive plays that played large roles in the game.
Receiver Tennel Bryant took a screen pass and eluded ISU defenders down the left sideline for a 70-yard touchdown for the game’s lone TD late in the third quarter.
“It’s unbelievable that we couldn’t get him knocked out of bounds,” Spack said. “We got blocked at the point of attack, but then there’s other (tacklers) that were coming. I didn’t understand the angles that they took.”
The second chunk play came with under three minutes remaining in the game. USD freshman running back Courtney Rivers broke off a 78-yard run to the ISU 13-yard line. The run led to a 35-yard field goal that gave the Coyotes a 10-3 lead.
“We missed a tackle right in the hole. We had him stopped for no gain. We fell off the tackle, and he was out the gate,” Spack said.
Replay reversals thwart Redbirds
A pair of replay reversals turned into game-altering plays.
The first occurred halfway through the first quarter. USD quarterback Austyn Modrzewski appeared to have fumbled while under pressure from ISU defensive back Doreon Dubose. Redbird linebacker Mason Kaplan scooped up the loose ball and returned it 43 yards for an apparent touchdown.
However, the replay booth overturned the call, ruling the play to be an incomplete pass.
Spack said he did get an explanation from the game officials.
“My only question was if it wasn’t a fumble (then) how come it wasn’t (intentional) grounding,” Spack said. “We can’t put ourselves in that situation.”
Kaplan, one of 23 players honored on Senior Day, said officials “are humans.”
“As a player, my responsibility is to go play,” he said. “We don’t really have a say.”
The second reversal came after field officials signaled first down on a Dawson run to the South Dakota 39-yard line on a 4th-and-2 snap. However, the replay booth official ruled Dawson down before making the first down.
“That one clearly looked like he made it, but again that call went upstairs and they turned it over,” Spack said. “Both side judges signaled first down.”
Last-ditch effort
Illinois State did manage to string together a late-game drive that covered 59 yards to reach the South Dakota 16-yard line.
“It’s good to get that kind of momentum going at the end of the game,” Pellant said.
However, Pellant’s final four passes fell incomplete and USD took over on downs and took a knee to seal the victory.
Game changers
8:39, 1st quarter: A booth replay reverses what would have been a 43-yard fumble return for a touchdown by Kaplan.
5:22, 3rd quarter: South Dakota took a 7-3 lead on a 70-yard pass play from Modrzewski to Bryant.
0:16, 4th quarter: Pellant’s fourth-down pass intended for receiver Dylan Lord fell incomplete.
Best ‘Birds
Prairie State Pigskin chooses the top three Illinois State players in the game:
Kaplan, LB: The sixth-year player led the team with eight tackles, one for loss. He was also credited with a quarterback hurry.
La’Shavion Brown, S: The senior registered six tackles, four of which were solo. He also broke up a deep pass play.
Dexter Niekamp, LB: The junior recorded six tackles, three of which were solo. He collected two sacks.
What it means
Illinois State missed out on an opportunity for a possible Top 8-seed and first-round bye with the loss.
What’s next
The Redbirds await the 24-team FCS playoff bracket to be revealed at 11 a.m. Sunday on ESPNU.
Dan Verdun is a co-founder of Prairie State Pigskin. He has written four books: NIU Huskies Football, EIU Panthers Football, ISU Redbirds Football and SIU Salukis Football.
Find us on social media!
Twitter: https://twitter.com/PSPigskin
Facebook: Prairie State Pigskin
Instagram: Prairiestatepigskin
Blue Sky: PSPigskin

Leave a Reply