Eastern Illinois Devin Whitlock accounted for 185 all-purpose yards in Saturday’s 20-17 Eastern Illinois overtime win at O’Brien Field. (Photo by Sandy King, EIUPanthers.com)
By Dan Verdun
Two years after one of the wildest finishes in O’Brien Field history, Eastern Illinois again tipped Charleston Southern in Saturday’s Senior Day regular-season finale.
EIU junior Drew Schiller’s field goal in the extra period proved to be the game-winner in a 20-17 victory.
Moments after Schiller’s 27-yarder gave the Panthers the lead, Charleston Southern kicker Matt Rolader missed wide right on a 30-yard attempt.
While both teams finished the season with 4-8 overall records, EIU posted a 3-4 mark in the Ohio Valley Conference. Charleston Southern ended 1-6 in the league.
“(I’m) so happy for the guys in the locker room, the seniors especially,” EIU head coach Chris Wilkerson said.
EIU managed just 82 yards on 31 plays in the first half. Meanwhile, CSU ran 27 plays for 176 yards. The Buccaneers only threw one pass, which went for 11 yards, in the first half. Nevertheless, CSU built a 10-0 lead.
“The first half was not pretty, especially right out of the shoot,” Wilkerson said. “You never know (with) Senior Day. The emotions are high. We get them in a third down and bam, they pop off a 73-yard run.”
Second-half success
Eastern regrouped in the second half. Both teams produced big plays as well as suffering from mistakes as the lead bounced back and forth.
“We made some adjustments at halftime and our defense did a really good job in the second half,” Wilkerson said. “Our offense did a much better job in the second half. Guys stepped up and made plays for us.”
Two of those “guys” were backup quarterback Jeremiah Salem and receiver Devin Whitlock.
Salem came off to the bench to relieve starter Cole LaCrue. The graduate student transfer from FBS Eastern Michigan completed 21 of 35 passes for 172 yards and a touchdown.
“This is a good way to cap it off. I couldn’t write a better ending,” Salem said.
Whitlock, a transfer from Division II Indiana (Penn.), amassed 185 all-purpose yards, including a 76-yard, end-around touchdown run.
“Everything that we were running was there,” Whitlock said.
Charleston Southern – dealing with a high number of injuries – ran a combination of backs from a wildcat formation in the backfield. CSU threw just five passes in the game – by three different players.
The Buccaneers’ Hakeem Watters rushed for 171 yards on 28 carries. Watters scored a pair of touchdowns – a 73-yarder in the first quarter and a 72-yarder in the third quarter.
“They caught us on our heels early,” Wilkerson said. “Later, even though we knew it was coming, they had another 70-plus yard run.”
Yet, in the end, Eastern prevailed.
“We found a way to make just enough plays to have three more points than our opponent,” Wilkerson said.
Game changers
2:37, 3rd quarter: Salem connected with receiver Eli Evans for a 21-yard touchdown pass. Schiller added the extra point, cutting CSU’s lead to 10-7.
0:42, 3rd quarter: Whitlock ran 76 yards for a touchdown, giving Eastern a 14-10 lead.
OT: Schiller’s 27-yard field goal provided the winning margin.
Prime Time Panthers
Prairie State Pigskin chooses the the top three Eastern Illinois players in the game:
Salem, QB: The Michigan native helped rally Eastern to victory with 172 passing yards and a touchdown throw to Evans.
Whitlock, WR: The redshirt junior accounted for 185 all-purpose yards (87 rushing, 68 receiving, 30 returning punts).
Schiller, K: The redshirt sophomore nailed two field goals, including the game-winner in overtime. He also kicked two PATs. Schiller made 7 of 8 field goal attempts and was 29 of 30 on extra points for the season.
What it means
Eastern avoids going winless for the season at O’Brien Field.
What’s next
EIU opens the 2027 season Aug. 28 at FBS Ole Miss.
Dan Verdun is a co-founder of Prairie State Pigskin. He has written four books: NIU Huskies Football, EIU Panthers Football, ISU Redbirds Football and SIU Salukis Football.
Find us on social media!
Twitter: https://twitter.com/PSPigskin
Facebook: Prairie State Pigskin
Instagram: Prairiestatepigskin
Blue Sky: PSPigskin

Leave a Reply